Cases › board:POST2303451

POST case 2303451

POST board · board proceeding · James Mutuku · Riverside Police Department
Case id
POST2303451
POST number
2303451
Incident dates
2022-10-01 – 2022-10-08 (3 incidents)
Category
dishonesty
POST outcome
revocation at posaab, 2024-10-17

Summary model-written

Sergeant James Mutuku was terminated from the Riverside Police Department after creating and posting 'Rat Busters' flyers and subsequently lying about the conduct during internal and POST investigations. The Division found clear and convincing evidence of dishonesty, and the POSAAB voted 4-3 to recommend the revocation of his certification.

Officer

Name
James Mutuku
POST ID
C25-A69 (id)
Name in NPI
JAMES M MUTUKU

Search within this case's documents →

Proceedings 10

Extracted and classified by a model, quote is verbatim from source text

  1. 2023-07-12
    agency
    terminated
    source · quote found
    The Respondent was terminated from the Riverside Police Department on July 12, 2023, resulting from three sustained findings (Conduct Unbecoming of an Officer, Retaliation, and Dishonesty).
    page 248
  2. 2023-10-12
    agency
    conducted Skelly hearing
    source · quote found
    On October 12, 2023, a Skelly hearing was conducted and attended by the Respondent, Saku Ethir (Respondent’s attorney), Deputy Chief Frank Assumma and Police Chief Larry Gonzalez.
    page 248
  3. 2023-10-19
    agency
    notified Respondent of decision to terminate employment
    source · quote found
    In a memorandum dated October 19, 2023, Police Chief Gonzalez notified the Respondent that his decision was to terminate Respondent’s employment with the Riverside Police Department.
    page 248
  4. 2023-10-20
    agency
    terminated
    source · quote found
    Sergeant Mutuku was terminated from the Riverside Police Department on October 20th, 2023
    page 348
  5. 2023-10-26
    agency
    reported the allegations of serious misconduct against the Respondent to POST pursuant to California Penal Code Section 13510.9
    source · quote found
    On October 26, 2023, the Riverside Police Department reported the allegations of serious misconduct against the Respondent to POST pursuant to California Penal Code Section 13510.9.
    page 231
  6. 2023-11-07
    agency
    withdrew appeal to the Skelly hearing findings
    source · quote found
    On November 29, 2023, POST received a supplement from the Riverside Police Department noting that the Respondent withdrew his appeal to the Skelly hearing findings. The withdrawal date was November 7, 2023.
    page 249
  7. 2024-05-13
    division
    conducted an interview
    source · quote found
    On May 13th, 2024, POST conducted an interview with Sergeant Mutuku.
    page 348
  8. 2024-05-21
    division
    served Investigative Summary and Findings and Notice of Intent to Revoke
    Certification: revocation
    source · quote found
    Respondent was served with the Division's Investigative Summary and Findings and accompanying Notice of Intent to Revoke, notifying Respondent that the Division had found reasonable grounds for revocation of Respondent's POST certification, on May 21, 2024.
    page 319
  9. 2024-06-07
    respondent
    requested a review of the Division's determination and reasons for revocation
    source · quote found
    Respondent requested a review of the Division's determination and reasons for revocation of Respondent's POST certification on June 7, 2024
    page 319
  10. 2024-10-17
    posaab
    held hearing and recommended revocation
    Certification: revocation · vote 4-3
    source · quote found
    BOARD CHAIR DUDLEY: So there are four votes for revocation, therefore the motion passes and the recommendation of this committee to the Commission is revocation.
    page 395

Incidents 3

DateConductCategoryFindingDiscipline / outcome
2022-10-01/2024-05-13 The Respondent was dishonest by adamantly denying that he created, printed, saw, touched, or placed the flyers during two separate interviews with Internal Affairs and a third interview with the POST investigator on May 13, 2024. dishonesty sustained
Division: clear and convincing evidence that the Respondent engaged in dishonesty as defined in Penal Code 13510.8(b)(1) and California Regulation 1205(a)(1)
terminated
Evidence · quote found
The Respondent was interviewed two separate times by Internal Affairs. In both interviews, the Respondent was dishonest by adamantly denying that he created, printed, saw, touched, or placed the flyers. Respondent continued to be dishonest when I interviewed him on May 13, 2024.
2022-10-08 The Respondent created, printed, and posted flyers with a picture of a crossed-out rat and the words, “Rat Busters” written below that image in the Complainant’s (work) mailbox and areas in the men’s locker room where the Complainant frequented. dishonesty sustained
Division: clear and convincing evidence that the Respondent engaged in dishonesty as defined in Penal Code 13510.8(b)(1) and California Regulation 1205(a)(1)
terminated
Evidence · quote found
The Respondent created, printed, and posted flyers with a picture of a crossed-out rat and the words, “Rat Busters” written below that image.
2022-10-08 confronted a complainant and formed a handgun with his hand, pointed it at the complainant, and acted like he fired it twice — unknown —
Evidence · quote found
the Respondent then turned, …he formed a – a handgun with his hand and pointed it at me and acted like he fired it twice.

Documents 53

agency investigation 12

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
Riverside Police Department Administrative Investigation PA2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim investigation report 2022-04-10 155 Board filed under case
Riverside Police Department Internal Affairs Interview of Officer C1 (File #PA2211047) interview transcript 2022-11-08 62 Board filed under case
Riverside Police Department Interview of Sergeant James Mutuku (PA2211047) interview transcript 2023-01-19 38 Board filed under case
Riverside PD Internal Affairs Interview of Sergeant James Mutuku (Volume 2), PA2211047 interview transcript 2023-02-21 18 Board filed under case
434 - BR3_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_B.pdf investigation report 2024-10-17 155 Board packet item
434 - BR4_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_C_.pdf interview transcript 2024-10-17 62 Board packet item
434 - BR10_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_I.pdf interview transcript 2024-10-17 38 Board packet item
434 - BR14_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_M.pdf interview transcript 2024-10-17 18 Board packet item
462 - BR3_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_B.pdf investigation report 2024-11-21 155 Board packet item
462 - BR4_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_C_.pdf interview transcript 2024-11-21 62 Board packet item
462 - BR10_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_I.pdf interview transcript 2024-11-21 38 Board packet item
462 - BR14_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_M.pdf interview transcript 2024-11-21 18 Board packet item

board proceeding 13

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
POST Investigative Summary and Findings - James Mutuku (POST2303451) investigative summary 2024-06-03 24 Board filed under case
POSAAB Agenda Item Report - POST2303451 James Mutuku agenda item report 2024-09-25 2 Board filed under case
POSAAB Agenda Item Report - James Mutuku (POST2303451) agenda item report 2024-09-25 2 Board filed under case
POST Agenda Item Report - James Mutuku (POST2303451) agenda item report 2024-09-25 3 Board filed under case
434 - Cover Page agenda item report 2024-10-17 2 Board packet item
434 - BR1_POST2302451_Mutuku_James_ISF_2_ (1).pdf investigative summary 2024-10-17 24 Board packet item
POSAAB Meeting Transcript October 17, 2024 hearing transcript 2024-10-17 69 Board filed under case
POSAAB Board Recommendation re: Peace Officer Certification of James Mutuku board recommendation 2024-10-17 3 Board filed under case
462 - Cover Page agenda item report 2024-11-21 3 Board packet item
462 - BR1_POST2302451_Mutuku_James_ISF_2_ (1).pdf investigative summary 2024-11-21 24 Board packet item
462 - POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Board_Recommendation_Signed.pdf board recommendation 2024-11-21 3 Board packet item
462 - POST2303451_Mutuku_James_October_2024_POSAAB_Agenda_Record.pdf posaab agenda record 2024-11-21 6 Board packet item
462 - POST2303451_James Mutkuku_10.17.2024 POSAAB Transcript.pdf hearing transcript 2024-11-21 69 Board packet item

criminal case 1

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
Riverside County Sheriff's Department Fingerprint Identification Email - Case PA2211047 forensic report 2023-01-20 2 Board filed under case

discipline and employment 6

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
Riverside Police Department Notice of Termination - James Mutuku discipline 2023-10-19 2 Board filed under case
Commission on POST Profile Report - James Mutuku personnel record 2024-01-23 4 Board filed under case
434 - BR2_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_A.pdf personnel record 2024-10-17 4 Board packet item
434 - BR16_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Attachment_O.pdf discipline 2024-10-17 2 Board packet item
462 - BR2_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_A.pdf personnel record 2024-11-21 4 Board packet item
462 - BR16_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Attachment_O.pdf discipline 2024-11-21 2 Board packet item

evidence 21

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
Riverside PD Email Chain regarding Print Queue Investigation communications 2022-11-29 2 Board filed under case
Riverside PD Asset Record N1450009 evidence log 2024-01-04 1 Board filed under case
Riverside PD Asset Record N1450009 (Case 221104700) evidence log 2024-01-04 1 Board filed under case
434 - BR6_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_E.png photograph 2024-10-17 1 Board packet item
434 - BR8_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Attachment_G.png photograph 2024-10-17 1 Board packet item
434 - BR7_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Attachment_F.jpg photograph 2024-10-17 1 Board packet item
434 - BR9_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Attachment_H.jpeg photograph 2024-10-17 1 Board packet item
434 - BR12_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_K.pdf communications 2024-10-17 2 Board packet item
434 - BR13_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_L.pdf communications 2024-10-17 2 Board packet item
462 - BR6_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_E.png photograph 2024-11-21 1 Board packet item
462 - BR7_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Attachment_F.jpg photograph 2024-11-21 1 Board packet item
462 - BR8_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Attachment_G.png photograph 2024-11-21 1 Board packet item
462 - BR9_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Attachment_H.jpeg photograph 2024-11-21 1 Board packet item
462 - BR12_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_K.pdf communications 2024-11-21 2 Board packet item
462 - BR13_POST2303451_Mutuku_James_Redacted_Attachment_L.pdf communications 2024-11-21 2 Board packet item
Exhibit: Cartoon Image and Equipment Notice photograph — 1 Board filed under case
Photograph of 'RATBUSTERS' Sign photograph — 1 Board filed under case
Exhibit Photograph: Rat Cartoon and Equipment Notice photograph — 1 Board filed under case
Photograph of Complainant's Inbox Filing Cabinet photograph — 1 Board filed under case
Photograph of Complainant's Inbox Filing Cabinet photograph — 1 Board filed under case
Photograph of 'RATBUSTERS' Sign photograph — 1 Board filed under case