Documents › 165b42545ccec2ddc6943d05f9754ece7e585010:1-1
Ventura PD Defensive Tactics Expert Interview regarding Officer Almaguer
About this document
- Layer
- agency record: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- ia interview transcript (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- ventura-police-department/2025-23950 Almaguer/DTAC_SGT_INTERVIEW_REDACTED_ (1).m4a
- File
- 165b42545ccec2ddc6943d05f9754ece7e585010 video/mp4
- Cases
Page 1 · file page 1
Text: speech transcript (machine)
machine transcript, speakers not labelled
- It is 6-2-2025 at 0748 hours.
- What I'm going to do is take a look at a bit of video.
- We are looking at body-worn camera footage from 4-18-2025.
- I'm going to move up to, or I'm going to advance the video rather.
- For context, this is a 10-8-5-2-1-48 call, and I'm going to start playing at 35 seconds.
- Stop resisting!
- Stop resisting!
- Oh! Hey bro! Hey, hey!
- Hey bro! Hey bro!
- Hey!
- Ah!
- Ah!
- Hey my brother!
- Bro! Bro!
- Bro my ear!
- Ah!
- Ah!
- Oh!
- okay so again we watched until i just stopped at 128 uh from your opinion as a in-house subject
- matter expert for our defensive tactics um kind of want to know your thoughts on just first view
- of it and they'll get some more pointed questions okay so first impression I
- have personal experience with this subject as I know these officers do
- he is known to fight so assaultive resistance previous and and run
- consistently so I do know that I have a couple concerns you know it's what the
- view from the camera it's hard to tell exactly what um what happens but clearly
- conducts the takedown starts to roll him over uh there is a concern that his left hand is concealed
- uh under his body and does appear to be at his waistband um so there's a concern i know he hasn't
- been checked for weapons but um so there's a concern there he does appear to be actively
- I'm thrashing around, and with his past history, definitely a concern there.
- Does he have complete control of him at that point when it appears Officer Almaguer makes his entrance?
- There is a concern.
- It appears Officer Almaguer does place his shin or knee on the subject's face or neck area.
- So there is a concern there.
- there. Timing-wise, it looks like it appears his intention is to help control, to prevent
- his escape and hold him down until he's cuffed, which obviously that's released once he's
- handcuffed. There are some concerns about the placement of the knee. It's hard exactly
- to tell exactly where it was. I don't know if Officer Almaguer articulated exactly where that
- was. He does say, ow, my ear. So that leads me to believe that it's placed somewhere on the head,
- which again would be just the concern is a risk of injury to the neck for the subject. So it
- appears he's trying to control his upper body with his leg. So that placement is a little
- concerning just out of a risk of hurting the subject okay in in our defensive
- tactics program are there times where we train our officers to either apply
- pressure or body weight to the head or do any sort of strikes to that well so
- pressure definitely controlling the head we definitely train that with multiple
- officer apprehension, not specifically with the knee or shin, but we do believe controlling the
- head controls the body. That is a premise that we teach as a fundamental. So controlling his head
- prevents him from escaping, which I believe was effective in this case, prevented him from getting
- away. And, you know, controlling the upper body, we do teach, you know, placing of the knee or the
- the shin on the upper back shoulder area to control, particularly with some of our handcuffing
- techniques. So yes, we do teach to control the head and the upper body, especially particularly
- when this is down at the lower body. That would be the appropriate place to go.
- Okay, backing up a little bit.
- If you go by the clock, or the time stamps rather, it looks like the knee or shin is
- first applied at 0056 into the video, and does not come off to approximately 30 seconds
- later. And let's just watch it back from 56 to 136 again. I'd like to know if you see
- a point where an adjustment should have been made in your opinion and again this is we are not
- expecting hindsight is 2020 we don't expect absolute perfection in the field but just from a
- a training and detox standpoint
- Yeah, watching it back, it appears there's an opportunity to transition,
- which would be probably a more preferable pressure application by, you know,
- using his hands to press down on the backs of the shoulders to hold him down
- or control the head with the hands instead of the shin.
- I do understand that there is a moment,
- particularly that adjustment could be made once his hand is removed from his waistband,
- from underneath his body.
- That seems like an appropriate time to make that adjustment.
- At the same time, it is helpful for him to have his hands available to him
- to where he is able to the handcuffs so yes I think there could have been an
- adjustment made particularly using his hands to hold the head down to the
- ground in the back of the shoulder rather than using his shin during that
- time at the same time I wasn't there to feel what he's feeling if he's pushing
- up or or not and he felt like he needed that pressure to remain so and having
- Having his hands available to help handcuff, I think, was helpful in this case.
- But I think there could have been an adjustment, for sure.
- Okay.
- After viewing this and knowing the little context you have,
- anything else you think we should be aware of as investigators reviewing this?
- I mean, I would note, as soon as he's handcuffed,
- the pressure is released from his neck and head.
- So I do believe Officer Almaguer appears to be aware of, like, where he placed his leg to control him.
- So I don't perceive it to be extremely excessive or anything like that to where he's not just, you know,
- seemingly punishing him by holding his leg on his neck.
- It's more of once he's in custody, okay, let's, you know, which, in my opinion,
- and gives the perception that his intention was merely to assist
- and safely take him into custody instead of trying to injure.
- Okay.
- All right.
- It is 7.57, and we are out of here.
- Thank you.
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.