Documents › 1673b26d637462e91d4484f0c372851e40446fc8:352-378

594 - BR01_POST2410050_Kim_Michael_ISF.pdf

POST board investigative summaryboard proceeding 2025-10-09 27 pages (file pages 352–378) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
isf (kind from doc_type)
File
1673b26d637462e91d4484f0c372851e40446fc8 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2410050 · Michael Kim (packet item)

About: Michael Kim (case)

Page 14 · file page 365 larger image
Image of page 14; its text is alongside
Text: digital text layer
 
 
Investigative Summary and Findings 
 
 
Michael Kim (Respondent) 
 
 
Case Number POST2410050 
Page 14 of 27 
 
Neither POST Regulations nor SFSO policy provide for further psychological 
evaluations after a second opinion’s determination of not suitable.44  Consequently, it is 
a reasonable conclusion that SFSO’s rejection letter should have closed the application 
process.  According to Lieutenant Tiffany Martin, SFSO did not have an appeal 
process for further review after a rejection like the one Kim received.45  On the other 
hand, according to Sergeant Fonthal, there was no SFSO policy prohibiting an appeal.  
In Respondent’s case, Sheriff Miyamoto called either Sergeant Fonthal or Lieutenant 
Martindale (who share an office) and told them to “pause” Respondent’s background 
investigation after Respondent’s own psychologist determined he was “not suitable.”46   
 
In February 2024, Respondent submitted an appeal of his own psychologist’s 
evaluation that he was not suitable for a position as a peace officer by providing a letter 
purportedly from Sheriff Miyamoto to Dr. Dunnigan.47  The letter is unsigned, undated, 
and is not on SFSO letterhead.  According to Deputy Wan, Dr. Dunnigan called him to 
authenticate the letter.  Deputy Wan had not seen the letter and was otherwise 
unaware of it.  Dr. Dunnigan told Deputy Wan that he would call Sheriff Miyamoto to 
verify the letter.  As an investigator, Deputy Wan stated that he was suspicious of the 
letter’s authenticity.48  Deputy Wan did not know whether Dr. Dunnigan verified the 
letter’s authenticity with Sheriff Miyamoto.  Sergeant Fonthal saw the letter when it 
came in as an attachment to a report Dr. Dunnigan submitted based on the February 
2024 appeal. 
 
The letter stated: 
 
As the elected Sheriff of San Francisco, one of my responsibilities is the hiring of 
sworn members of the Department.  I am familiar with what Mike experienced 
when he left the Sheriff’s Office, as well as his experiences at the War Memorial 
Veteran’s Building.  I have no concerns at this time of bringing him back as a 
member of the Sheriff’s Office.49 
 
According to Dr. Dunnigan’s report: 
 
Mr. Kim reached out [to Dr. Dunnigan] again in February 2024.  He informed this 
examiner that the investigation at his security company had been completed and 
that the allegations had not been sustained. Mr. Kim also stated that he had 
received a letter from Sheriff Miyamoto strongly supporting him and his believed 
 
44  Attachment O (Mel Fonthal Report of Interview at 3 (4/16/2025)). 
45 Attachment Q (Tiffany Martin Report of Interview at 1 (3/11/2025)). 
46 Although there were no orders to give updates to Sheriff Miyamoto, there was an “understanding” that 
the Sheriff wanted updates regarding Respondent’s background investigation.  Attachment O (Mel 
Fonthal Report of Interview at 1 (4/16/2025)). 
47 Attachment R (Letter from Paul Miyamoto to “To Whom It May Concern” (undated)). 
48 Attachment N (Ronnie Wan Report of Interview at 3 (3/11/2025)). 
49 Attachment R (Letter from Paul Miyamoto to “To Whom It May Concern” (undated)). 
365

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.