Documents › 1673b26d637462e91d4484f0c372851e40446fc8:519-522
594 - BR16_POST2410050_O_Fonthal_Final_ROI_Redacted.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- case_attachment (kind from title)
- File
- 1673b26d637462e91d4484f0c372851e40446fc8 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Michael Kim (case)
Page 1 · file page 519
larger image
Text: digital text layer
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
GAVIN NEWSOM, Governor
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
ROB BONTA, Attorney General
Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training
860 Stillwater Road
West Sacramento, CA 95605-1603
www.post.ca.gov
The mission of the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training is to continually enhance
the professionalism of California law enforcement in serving its communities.
On April 16, 2025, California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training
(“POST”) Law Enforcement Consultants Kevin Sherburne and James Saso interviewed Mel
Fonthal1 in a conference room located at 120 14th Street, San Francisco, California.
Communications by the parties during the interview were electronically recorded. The
recording will serve as the true and accurate record of the statements made by Fonthal.
After being advised of the identity of the interviewers and the purpose of the interview, that
being to obtain information related to allegations of serious misconduct, Fonthal provided
the following information:
Fonthal has been with the San Francisco Sheriff’s Office (“SFSO”) for about 13
years. In that time, he has served approximately three years each in jails, patrol, criminal
investigations, and the past three years in the Background Investigations Unit (“BIU”). He
is a sergeant in BIU and was initially assigned to BIU in April 2022.
When he first started in BIU, Fonthal was the watch commander as sergeant. There
was no lieutenant. About six to eight months after he arrived, SFSO restructured, adding
the CCW program to BIU and added a lieutenant. That lieutenant is still in BIU and he is
Darin Martindale.
BIU uses Guardian Alliance to track background investigations the investigators
perform. Access to Guardian is limited to Personnel, Command Staff, and Background
Investigators/BIU.
Deputy Ronnie Wan was in BIU prior to Fonthal’s arrival. Now-Lieutenant Tiffany
Martin was the sergeant at the time and she spent about six to eight months working to
train Fonthal. Wan’s assignment includes both Personnel and Background Investigator. At
the time Kim applied, background files were assigned by either Martindale or Fonthal.
Their tasks are not “super separated.”
Fonthal worked with Kim about 12 years ago. He did not work under him and only
saw him in passing. He does not have a relationship with Kim.
“Everybody” raised concerns and had comments about whether Kim should be
rehired. Fonthal knew of his past and was concerned whether Kim could legally be a
peace officer. Fonthal did not know what POST might say about Kim and did not know the
outcome of any charges against Kim.
Although there were voiced concerns, BIU’s responsibility was to conduct
background investigations. The unit’s response to the concerns was that he was legally
allowed to apply just like everyone else and Kim was not the first to leave and come back to
reapply at SFSO. There was no pressure from command staff to hire Kim. The direction to
Wan was “work the file.” Paul Miyamoto said, “just work it.” Miyamoto just wanted to see a
full file.
1 On May 12, 2025, Kevin Sherburne revised the Report of Interview of Mel Fonthal to correct the identity of the
witness being interviewed. The original incorrectly stated that Ronnie Wan was the witness.
519
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.