Documents › 1673b26d637462e91d4484f0c372851e40446fc8:711-713
594 - BR31_POST2410050_Dunnigan_Final Report of POST interview
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- case_attachment (kind from title)
- File
- 1673b26d637462e91d4484f0c372851e40446fc8 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Michael Kim (case)
Page 2 · file page 712
larger image
Text: digital text layer
Interview of Ryan Dunnigan
June 25, 2025
Page 2
The mission of the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training is to continually enhance
the professionalism of California law enforcement in serving its communities.
letters from a sheriff or chief in his role as an evaluator. That made the letter memorable
and very rare that a sheriff or chief would step into the process.
The letter carried “considerable weight” because it leans into Dunnigan’s lane in the
road. Kim performed fairly well on both psychometric tests, his personality traits were
pretty well-rounded, and there was nothing there that would preclude him from moving
forward on those bases. What concerned Dunnigan was information in Kim’s background
investigation. After he came back and said the investigation at the War Memorial had
concluded and was not sustained, coupled with the sheriff’s letter, Dunnigan’s position was
that, if you want him, and he’s psychiatrically stable, that’s your department and you can do
that.
Dunnigan noted the letter from Miyamoto was not on letterhead, which could have
been because he wrote it as his buddy, not coworker. Dunnigan did not recall if he asked
anyone at the Sheriff’s Office about the letter. He did not call the Sheriff. Dunnigan did not
solicit the letter. Dunnigan did not tell Kim that, if the War Memorial investigation went
away, he could mark Kim as suitable. That would have been up to the Sheriff’s Office.
Dunnigan did not recall speaking with Deputy Ronnie Wan about the letter.
If there is an appeals process after a finding by a secondary evaluator, that’s up to
the hiring department. Normally, the candidate is out for a certain amount of time. Here, it
was very strange that they reopened the case after Dunnigan’s finding of not suitable.
Maybe the Sheriff and Kim were buddies or colleagues. During interviews with Kim,
Kim made it known to Dunnigan that he and the Sheriff knew each other for a long time and
that he was “really close” and “very close,” and went up the ranks together, or statements
that the Sheriff was great and really wanted Kim there.
Kim told Dunnigan that he had spoken with people in the Sheriff’s Office, but other
than the Sheriff, Dunnigan was not sure with whom Kim had spoken.
The evaluations take an hour or two. Some go longer. There was a lot of stuff in
Kim’s file that concerned Dunnigan. Even during the second evaluation, Dunnigan was
hesitant to sign off on Kim but if the Sheriff wanted to “take that liability” and they were
comfortable with Kim, they have that right. Dunnigan found the contempt charge
disturbing. That’s a big deal to Dunnigan.
Kim tended to gloss over things and minimize his role. He did not take
accountability for his own actions. It was a little incongruent compared to the gravity of the
situation. The To Whom It May Concern weighed a lot. Dunnigan just did not feel
comfortable with him without that letter. Dunnigan likely would have failed Kim were it not
for the letter. If he were a chief or sheriff, he would not have hired Kim.
Dunnigan is familiar with the POST Dimensions in background investigations. Kim’s
statement to Dunnigan about the contempt conviction was framed in terms of downplaying
certain things and highlighting that Kim was protecting the Sheriff’s Office by resigning and
that they dropped the charge from a felony to a misdemeanor. The contempt charge was a
712
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.