Documents › 3ff9c5a7f07a7bdb7508cce9958d23f06fb874b2:1-80

POSAAB Meeting Transcript - April 15, 2026

POST board hearing transcriptboard proceeding 2026-04-15 80 pages (file pages 1–80) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
board hearing transcript (kind from doc_type)
File
3ff9c5a7f07a7bdb7508cce9958d23f06fb874b2 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2311370 · Jose Zavala (filed under case)

About: Jose Zavala (case)

Page 66 · file page 66 larger image
Image of page 66; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

POSAAB Meeting, April 15, 2026

1 MS. WILCOX: It is not a perfect system.

2 VICE CHAIRPERSON DOYLE: At this time, does the
3 Board --

4 MEMBER JOHNSON: Johnson. I'm sorry. Yeah. One
5 more question, and it's for Counsel.

6 California law, AB 392, talked about necessary
7 standard. Changing the reasonable standard.

8 We are to follow the California law, correct?

9 MR. BEATTY: Yes. I mean, I think that's -- we can
10 look at both bodies of law to make an analysis on these
11 kinds of cases. But California law is going to be the
12 one that probably is the most guiding and that's going
13 to be following 13510. So yes.

14 MEMBER JOHNSON: Thank you.

15 MS. WOOLLEY: And, Mr. Beatty, if I could, the
16 Division's position as to what the legal standard here
17 is laid out in the ISFs under the analysis section. So
18 we do cite the recent Supreme Court case out of 2025,
19 Barnes v. Felix, which is a unanimous opinion of the
20 Supreme Court.

21 It does address that you do need to have objective,
22 reasonable conduct, but you also need to address the
23 totality of the circumstances in this case.

24 One of the things that was happening in the courts
25 was that they were starting to drift into a moment of

79

SWANK REPORTING INC. (916) 390-7731

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.