Documents › 62c7cdce7d871d32d0621b4fa0986bb333bbaa2f:20-35

San Bernardino Police Department Manager's Review Report 23PSB-082

POST board investigation reportagency investigation 2024-02-07 16 pages (file pages 20–35) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
File
62c7cdce7d871d32d0621b4fa0986bb333bbaa2f application/pdf
Cases
POST 2322062 · Hector Victorio (filed under case)

About: Hector Victorio (case)

Page 15 · file page 34 larger image
Image of page 15; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

§4.02 Neglect of Duty

Employees may be deemed incompetent and subject to discipline when they: fail to properly perform their assigned duties; act in a manner tending to bring discredit to themselves or the Department; or fail to assume responsibility or exercise diligence, intelligence, and interest in the pursuit of their duties.

Conclusion:

On November 27, 2023, Officer H. Victorio and Officer G. Rodriguez were involved in a high-speed pursuit where the suspect made several unsafe driving movements including driving on the opposite side of the road during daylight hours, driving through a school zone area at a high rate of speed. After the pursuit, officers used force to apprehend the suspect.

An investigation was conducted and what was uncovered was the lack of experience by the officers. The lack of experience between Rodriguez and Victorio was evident. When Victorio authored his report he wrote he believed the suspect was a danger to them; however, Victorio's actions did not prove this because he could have initiated a felony traffic stop and gathered additional resources to de-escalate the situation. Instead, Victorio immediately closed the distance and began to give commands.

Victorio observed Victim on his stomach facing the ground with arms extended in a non-threatening manner holding a blunt object. Victorio perceived Victim to be a threat and decided to strike Victim without deploying hand control techniques, bypassing the force options outlined in the policy; therefore, the strike was unreasonable. Additionally, Victorio's lack of experience did not allow him to accurately assess the threat. Further, Rodriguez recognized the threat, and he deployed hand control holds to overcome Victim's resistance.

Victorio deployed hand and knee strikes to Victim's head, which is against policy. It was evident that the techniques used by Victorio were improper and ineffective. These strikes used by Victorio could have led to injury and could have created a dangerous situation for himself and Rodriguez. Moreover, it was evident that Victorio's misinterpretation of Victim's actions was attributed to Victorio's lack of experience because Victorio described Victim's actions as resistance when in fact Victim was reacting to the strikes he received.

Although these policy violations are serious, these violations occurred because of Victorio's lack of experience (14 months since the date of hire as a police officer), and training. Further, this incident was investigated by the District Attorney's office which found the act was not criminal. Moreover, Victorio has no history of allegations of excessive force against him.

In this case, Victorio's actions were not malicious, intentional, or acting under the color of authority; instead, he acted in a manner where he made a bad decision and used bad

Page 14 of 15

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.