Daly City Police Department Administrative Investigative Memorandum 24-04 (Officer Smithmatungol)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- ia investigative memorandum (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 96e06f72db3e5e151c1b7bea10db9029b892e6b3 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)
possession. I explained to him that this was insufficient for identifying someone, as the card could have belonged to someone else, and we would have no way of knowing. I asked why he had not booked her, so she could be fingerprinted and properly identified. He said she was in the late stages of pregnancy and he did not want to have to take her to Chope for a medical clearance prior to being booked into jail. I asked if she had any local address or if she had provided a phone number. He said the suspect told him she was staying at a homeless shelter, but that she did not know the address, and that he had not obtained a phone number from her. I explained that if the suspect failed to show up to court, there would be no way of tracking her, and the charges would likely get dropped.
In briefings and casual conversations since the beginning of the watch, Lt. Klier, Sgt. Tualaulelei and I have stressed the importance of proper identification of suspects, and reiterated that if someone cannot be positively identified, they should be booked into San Mateo County Jail. Officer Smithmatungol was present for at least one of these conversations. I asked if he recalled these conversations. He told me he did not and was under the impression suspects could be issued citations without being positively identified. He then spontaneously stated he had obtained her fingerprint when issuing her the citation. This gave me hope that it could help with her identification, and I responded, "Oh great, you did?" He then said something along the lines of "Yeah, I got her thumbprint on the citation." I told him that was good, and that hopefully her print could identify her, if need be. We then wrapped up the conversation, and Officer Smithmatungol said he was sorry for not properly identifying her, and that he would handle situations like this better in the future. I told him that it was ok, and to just not let it happen again.
I had not previously seen what a thumbprint looked like on the new digital citation writers, so after Officer Smithmatungol left, I logged on to the Turbo Data website to see how it appeared with the new formatted digital tickets. I viewed his citation (#180035), and looked under the public copy and officer copy, but did not see a thumbprint. I was unfamiliar with how a thumbprint would be obtained on the writer, and also wanted to verify that what Officer Smithmatungol told me was accurate, so I logged on to evidence.com and reviewed his and Officer Rodriguez's BWC.
The BWC showed that Officer Smithmatungol used his citation writer (ID DCTR61) to begin the citation. He handed it to Officer Rodriguez, who began to assist with inputting the information. As this was happening, they were alerted to another shoplifter inside Target. They left and dealt with that subject (who was issued a citation, documented in case 24003453); after that subject was cited, Officer Smithmatungol returned to the suspect and finished issuing her a citation. At no point did he obtain her thumbprint on the citation, or via any other means. I learned that only certain writers have the ability to obtain a thumbprint and saw that this writer was not one of them. I reviewed all of the BWC and found no evidence that he or anyone else obtained the suspect's fingerprints, as Officer Smithmatungol had claimed.
On Saturday, 06/08/2024, Sgt. Tualaulelei and I met with Officer Smithmatungol. The purpose of the meeting was to discuss unrelated performance issues, including lack of self-initiated proactivity, and to seek clarification on the location of the citation. I began the meeting by mentioning the case, and asked if he remembered it. He said he did. I told him it appeared that
2 | Page
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.