Porterville PD Notice of Adverse Decision (Termination) - James Guy
About this document
- Layer
- agency record: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- discipline letter (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- porterville-police-department/22P37416-12.pdf
- File
- f2114b0366fd7ceefca885f929f9eb5fa2700295 application/pdf
- Cases
No. 22-471(f)
PORTERVILLE POLICE DEPARTMENT INTEROFFICE MEMO
December 12, 2022
TO: Mr. James Guy
Jake Castellow
FROM: Jake Castellow, Chief of Police
SUBJECT: Notice of Adverse Decision
On December 7, 2022, at approximately 0946 hours, I met with you and your representative, Steven Welch, in my office for your Skelly Conference per your request to respond to the intent to impose discipline as documented in Porterville Police Department Interoffice Memo No. 22-471.
During this conference, I listened to your explanations/reasoning, and any further information you thought needed to be addressed and the meeting concluded at 1004 hours.
Statement of Decision
After listening to your explanations/reasoning and my review of the entire investigation as presented by the investigators, and the additional information presented at Skelly, I do not feel that any modification of the proposed discipline is warranted.
In the presented analysis of the incident by your representative and you, it was perceived by you the use of force was "reasonable" and that, "the use of force would have been reasonable by any officer put in the same situation, presented with the same facts."
During the investigation, Tulare County Sheriff's Deputy Rufino Lopez was contacted and interviewed regarding this Internal Affairs Investigation. Deputy Lopez is considered to be a "reasonable" sworn law enforcement officer. In Deputy Lopez's witness statement, he said you took a few steps forward and pushed the inmate down. Deputy Lopez said you did this because it appeared the inmate spit on you. The deputy said you became upset and pushed the handcuffed inmate down. Deputy Lopez said the inmate fell to the ground and struck his head, causing a large wound which was bleeding.
Deputy Lopez told investigators he did not feel it was okay that you pushed the inmate merely because you were upset. Deputy Lopez said he does not react by pushing inmates, especially if they are in handcuffs.
In the Skelly Conference, it was presented by Mr. Welch that this was reasonable force as the suspect was advancing toward you in a "fighting mode" and the force used would have been reasonable by any other officer presented with the same set of facts. This conclusion is contradicted as stated above by a reasonable peace officer, Deputy Lopez, who did not think the force was reasonable and that he would not have reacted by pushing a handcuffed inmate to the ground.
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.