Documents › f651c444bc64236b982886b28e7e2e02181b99ab:308-309

356 - BR17_POST2300204_Hubbard_David_Redacted_Attachment_P_Rutter_Final_ROI.pdf

POST board investigation reportagency investigation 2024-06-12 2 pages (file pages 308–309) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
case_attachment (kind from title)
File
f651c444bc64236b982886b28e7e2e02181b99ab application/pdf
Cases
POST 2300204 · David Wesley Hubbard (packet item)

About: David Wesley Hubbard (case)

Page 1 · file page 308 larger image
Image of page 1; its text is alongside
Text: OCR figure: some text describes an image

STATE OF CALIFORNIA
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE

GAVIN NEWSOM, Governor
ROB BONTA, Attorney General

Figure: the OCR model's description, not text on the pageSeal of the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and TrainingThe seal of the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, featuring a star with a central emblem and the words "COMMISSION ON PEACE OFFICER STANDARDS AND TRAINING" around it.

Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training

860 Stillwater Road
West Sacramento, CA 95605-1603
www.post.ca.gov

On May 3, 2023, Bess Rutter was interviewed in a conference room located at the California Department of Consumer Affairs, Bureau of Automotive Repair, 3331 North Sillect Avenue, Bakersfield, California by Kevin Sherburne and Darryl Elliott, Law Enforcement Consultants at the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training ("POST"). Communications by the parties during the interview were electronically recorded. The recording will serve as the true and accurate record of the statements made by Rutter. After being advised of the identity of the interviewers and the purpose of the interview, that being to obtain information related to allegations of serious misconduct, Rutter provided the following information:

On May 3, 2023, Bess Rutter was interviewed in a conference room located at the California Department of Consumer Affairs, Bureau of Automotive Repair, 3331 North Sillect Avenue, Bakersfield, California by Kevin Sherburne and Darryl Elliott, Law Enforcement Consultants at the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training ("POST"). Communications by the parties during the interview were electronically recorded. The recording will serve as the true and accurate record of the statements made by Rutter. After being advised of the identity of the interviewers and the purpose of the interview, that being to obtain information related to allegations of serious misconduct, Rutter provided the following information:

Rutter was assigned to Internal Affairs ("IA") in 2021 and brought over to Professional Standards Unit ("PSU") in October 2021.

Rutter described the layout of PSU as an open room with desks in cubicles. Three cubicles on each side of the room. Rutter was on the north side toward the west. [REDACTED] V1 [REDACTED] was directly across from Rutter on the south and west sides. The opening of their cubicles was more or less aligned. [REDACTED] V1 [REDACTED] desk faced the wall and Rutter's desk faced the window, so they had their backs to each other. They could see each other's computer monitors if they turned around.

While at IA, they were in a different building on the Kern County Sheriff's Office ("KCSO") campus. When Rutter moved to PSU, [REDACTED] V1 [REDACTED] cubicle already had doors on it. Rutter understood that [REDACTED] V1 [REDACTED] wanted privacy and they were working with a group of guys and sometimes did not want to deal with them. They were all told doors were a fire hazard and no fake doors were allowed. [REDACTED] V1 [REDACTED] was a jokester. [REDACTED] V1 [REDACTED] mostly kept the doors open when Hubbard was there. When they were having discussions, Rutter thought something was not right. It was not a good look to have someone in your cubicle with you and you're whispering like Hubbard and [REDACTED] V1 [REDACTED] did. They were all in one unit and if something needed to be discussed, there should not have been secrets. Rutter could not overhear discussions in the cubicle. Siebert was in the cubicle right next to hers.

[REDACTED] V1 [REDACTED] was Hubbard's secretary and he was the lieutenant. He was professional. It was a relaxed atmosphere. Their relationship might have crossed a line. It seemed a little closer than Rutter would have been with her partners and Hubbard was [REDACTED] V1 [REDACTED] supervisor. But, Rutter was new to the unit and did not want to say anything.


The mission of the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training is to continually enhance the professionalism of California law enforcement in serving its communities.

308

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.