Cases › board:POST2402562

POST case 2402562

POST board · board proceeding · Armando R. Montalvo · Orange County Sheriff's Department/coroner
Case id
POST2402562
POST number
2402562
Agency case no.
24-009233
Incident dates
2023-05-09 – 2025-10-02 (7 incidents)
Category
physical abuse
POST outcome
revocation at posaab, 2025-10-09

Summary model-written

Deputy Armando Montalvo was alleged to have punched an inmate approximately 28 times and slammed the inmate's head into a concrete floor while the inmate was pinned down. The Division found clear and convincing evidence of serious misconduct, and the POSAAB recommended the revocation of his certification.

Officer

Name
Armando R. Montalvo
POST ID
C89-U13 (id)
Name in NPI
ARMANDO RODRIGO MONTALVO

Search within this case's documents →

Proceedings 7

Extracted and classified by a model, quote is verbatim from source text

  1. 2024-03-27
    agency
    reported the allegation of serious misconduct to POST pursuant to California Penal Code Section 13510.9
    source · quote found
    On March 27, 2024, the Orange County Sheriff’s Department reported the allegation of serious misconduct to POST pursuant to California Penal Code Section 13510.9.
    page 722
  2. 2024-12-23
    agency
    concluded the investigation, and allegations were sustained related to the force used by Respondent
    source · quote found
    On December 23, 2024, the Orange County Sheriff’s Department concluded the investigation, and allegations were sustained related to the force used by Respondent. Based on the sustained findings Respondent received a 40-hour suspension.
    page 722
  3. 2025-07-24
    division
    found reasonable grounds for suspension or revocation of a peace officer's certification
    Certification: other
    source · quote found
    The Peace Officer Standards Accountability Division, Certification Executive Review Panel has reviewed the above referenced case involving alleged serious misconduct and has determined the following: - There are reasonable grounds for suspension or revocation of a peace officer's certification.
    page 1
  4. 2025-08-12
    division
    served Investigative Summary and Findings and accompanying Notice of Intent to Revoke
    Certification: revocation
    source · quote found
    Respondent was served with the Division's Investigative Summary and Findings and accompanying Notice of Intent to Revoke, notifying Respondent that the Division had found reasonable grounds for revocation of Respondent's POST certification, on August 12, 2025.
    page 1
  5. 2025-08-20
    respondent
    requested a review of the Division's determination and reasons for revocation
    source · quote found
    Respondent requested a review of the Division's determination and reasons for revocation of Respondent's POST certification on August 20, 2025
    page 1
  6. 2025-10-09
    posaab
    held hearing
    source · quote found
    the Board scheduled the case for a hearing which was held on October 9, 2025.
    page 1
  7. 2025-10-09
    posaab
    recommended revocation
    Certification: revocation · vote six ayes
    source · quote found
    There's six ayes. Motion passes.
    page 2430

Incidents 7

DateConductCategoryFindingDiscipline / outcome
2023-05-09 alleged use of force; described as an inmate grievance — unfounded —
Evidence · quote found
The first reported incident was May 9th, 2023... I have the first was one as "unfounded" by the agency, closed with POST.
2023-06-04 alleged use of force; described as an inmate grievance — other —
Evidence · quote found
the second was June 4th, 2023... On the second one, I have "unfounded and exonerated."
2023-12-14 alleged use of force; described as an inmate grievance — unfounded —
Evidence · quote found
December 14th, 2023... On the third, I have "unfounded" by the agency.
2024-03-16 Respondent visibly punched INMATE approximately twenty-eight (28) times in the face, head, and upper body and slammed INMATE's face against the concrete floor while INMATE was pinned down by deputies. physical abuse sustained
Division: Clear and convincing evidence substantiated that Respondent violated California Penal Code §13510.8(b)(3) and Commission Regulation 1205(a)(3)
40-hour suspension
Evidence · quote found
While pinned face down to the ground by multiple deputies, Respondent punched INMATE in the head face and upper body, no less than 28 times... Respondent lifted INMATE’s head up, with two hands, and slammed it onto the concrete floor.
2024-03-21 alleged use of force; described as an inmate grievance — unfounded —
Evidence · quote found
March 21st, 2024... not including our case, the next one was "unfounded."
2024-09-20 alleged use of force; described as an inmate grievance — not sustained —
Evidence · quote found
and September 20th, 2024... And I have "not sustained" on the last one.
2025-10-02 indicated that Deputy Montalvo had used a punch — unknown —
Evidence · quote found
The final case that was submitted to POST on October 2nd, that we have not conducted the investigation on there indicated that Deputy Montalvo had used a punch.

Documents 32

agency investigation 1

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
POST Investigative Summary and Findings - Armando Montalvo (POST2402562) investigation report 2025-08-11 23 Board filed under case

board proceeding 15

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
POST Executive Review & Peace Officer Standards Accountability Division Recommendation - Armando Montalvo (POST2402562) executive review 2025-07-24 2 Board filed under case
637 - Cover Page agenda item report 2025-10-09 3 Board packet item
637 - BR01_POST2402562_Montalvo_Armando_ISF_Final (1).pdf investigative summary 2025-10-09 23 Board packet item
637 - BR02_POST2402562_Executive_Review_Division_Recomendation.pdf executive review 2025-10-09 2 Board packet item
POSAAB Agenda Item Report - Armando R. Montalvo (POST2402562) agenda item report 2025-10-09 3 Board filed under case
POSAAB Meeting Transcript October 9, 2025 hearing transcript 2025-10-09 81 Board filed under case
POSAAB Agenda Item Report: Armando R. Montalvo (POST2402562) agenda item report 2025-10-09 3 Board filed under case
POSAAB Board Recommendation re: Peace Officer Certification of Armando Montalvo board recommendation 2025-10-09 3 Board filed under case
649 - Cover Page agenda item report 2025-12-02 3 Board packet item
649 - BR01_POST2402562_Montalvo_Armando_ISF_Final (1).pdf investigative summary 2025-12-02 23 Board packet item
649 - BR02_POST2402562_Executive_Review_Division_Recomendation.pdf executive review 2025-12-02 2 Board packet item
649 - POST2402562_Montalvo_Armando_October_2025_POSAAB_Agenda_Record.pdf posaab agenda record 2025-12-02 6 Board packet item
649 - POST2402562_Montalvo_Armando_Board_Recommendation_Signed.pdf board recommendation 2025-12-02 3 Board packet item
649 - POST2402562_Montalvo_Armando_Transcript_Board_10.09.2025.pdf hearing transcript 2025-12-02 81 Board packet item
Agenda Item Report - Armando R. Montalvo (POST2402562) agenda item report 2025-12-03 3 Board filed under case

criminal case 13

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
Orange County Sheriff's Department Incident Report 24-009233 police report 2024-03-16 3 Board filed under case
Orange County Sheriff's Department Supplemental Narrative Report DR# 24-009233 police report 2024-03-16 1 Board filed under case
Orange County Sheriff's Department Supplemental Report DR #24-009233 (Deputy E. Chen) police report 2024-03-16 1 Board filed under case
Orange County Sheriff's Department Supplemental Report DR 24-009233 (Deputy N. Vega) police report 2024-03-16 2 Board filed under case
Orange County Sheriff's Department Supplemental Report 24-009233 police report 2024-03-16 1 Board filed under case
Orange County Sheriff's Department Supplemental Report 24-009233 police report 2024-03-16 1 Board filed under case
OCSD Supervisory Use of Force Supplemental Report 24-009233 police report 2024-03-18 1 Board filed under case
Orange County Sheriff's Department Supplemental Report 24-009233 police report 2024-03-18 1 Board filed under case
OCSD Use of Force Report 24-009233 police report 2024-04-01 8 Board filed under case
637 - BR05_POST2402562_Attachment_B_OCSD_Use_of_Force_Report_24-009233_Redacted.pdf police report 2025-10-09 8 Board packet item
637 - BR04_POST2402562_Attachment_A_OCSD_Report_24-009233_FINAL_Redacted.pdf police report 2025-10-09 11 Board packet item
649 - BR05_POST2402562_Attachment_B_OCSD_Use_of_Force_Report_24-009233_Redacted.pdf police report 2025-12-02 8 Board packet item
649 - BR04_POST2402562_Attachment_A_OCSD_Report_24-009233_FINAL_Redacted.pdf police report 2025-12-02 11 Board packet item

discipline and employment 3

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
POST Profile Report for Armando Rodrigo Montalvo personnel record 2025-08-20 2 Board filed under case
637 - BR03_POST2402562_EDI_Profile_Montalvo_Armando_Redacted.pdf personnel record 2025-10-09 2 Board packet item
649 - BR03_POST2402562_EDI_Profile_Montalvo_Armando_Redacted.pdf personnel record 2025-12-02 2 Board packet item