Documents › 1673b26d637462e91d4484f0c372851e40446fc8:719-741

637 - BR01_POST2402562_Montalvo_Armando_ISF_Final (1).pdf

POST board investigative summaryboard proceeding 2025-10-09 23 pages (file pages 719–741) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
isf (kind from doc_type)
File
1673b26d637462e91d4484f0c372851e40446fc8 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2402562 · Armando R. Montalvo (packet item)

About: Armando R. Montalvo (case)

Page 21 · file page 739 larger image
Image of page 21; its text is alongside
Text: digital text layer
 
 
 
 
 
19    
      Investigative Summary and Recommendation 
 
 
Armando Montalvo 
 
 
Case Number POST2402562  
     
 
• Respondent was working in a controlled environment (jail) where IN-
MATE would have already been searched for weapons and multiple dep-
uties were working within close proximity of each other (cover/backup). 
• Throughout the incident, captured on video, INMATE only appeared 
physically resistive by not immediately giving up his hands, while lying 
face down. No footage showed INMATE attempt to physically assault 
deputies, and no deputies were able to articulate that INMATE attempted 
to assault them.     
• While pinned face down to the ground by multiple deputies, Respondent 
punched INMATE in the head face and upper body, no less than 28 
times, while other deputies were punching INMATE.  Respondent contin-
ually punched INMATE without giving INMATE time to comply with verbal 
instructions. 
• While pinned to the ground by no less than four deputies, Respondent 
lifted INMATE’s head up, with two hands, and slammed it onto the con-
crete floor. 
• By Respondent’s own admission during his administrative interview, 
slamming INMATE’s head onto the concrete was an unapproved/un-
trained tactic.  Respondent also admitted that the force he used was un-
reasonable and excessive. 
• Sergeant Raphael noted that the force options were ineffective writing, 
“Four Deputies punched INMATE numerous times even though the in-
mate did not appear to be actively resisting.”1 
• Sergeant Raphael noted that the force options utilized in this incident 
were not reasonable under Policy 300 writing, ““The force used was not 
objectively reasonable or proportionate to the threat presented by the In-
mate. The application of force did not stop even though the Inmate did 
not appear to be actively/physically resisting.” 2  
• Sergeant Raphael noted training issues were identified writing, “Deputies 
did not employ tactical communication and/or de-escalation techniques 
prior to the use of force. Additionally, Deputies did not comply with Policy 
300.”3 
• Lieutenant Buffong noted training areas needed to be addressed and 
wrote, “Instead of using controlling force against the inmate, injuring 
force was used. Upon review, the force appeared ineffective and inappro-
priate for this incident.”4 
• Sergeant Raphael recommended the incident be forwarded for internal 
investigation. 5 
 
1 Attachment B- OCSD Use of Force Report 24-009233 Page 5 Question 2 
2 Attachment B- OCSD Use of Force Report 24-009233 Page 5 Question 3 
3 Attachment B- OCSD Use of Force Report 24-009233 Page 6 Question 7  
4 Attachment B- OCSD Use of Force Report 24-009233 Page 7 Question 3 
5 Attachment B- OCSD Use of Force Report 24-009233 Page 8 Sgt. Recommendation 
739

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.